Wednesday, November 19, 2025

The power of Mark Strong and Lesley Manville's performances in Broadway's 'Oedipus' will leave you drained

 


When I was in first grade our teacher used to trick us into being quiet by telling us to put our heads on our desks and listen for her to drop a pin.  It worked.  We were as still and quiet as we could be.  I thought of that Monday night as the tension mounted at director Robert Icke’s riveting reimagining of Sophocles’s Oedipus Rex.  The audience was intensely focused on the stage at Studio 54, spellbound by a story for which they already knew the outcome.  But then, it’s unlikely anyone has experienced anything like Icke’s Oedipus.

Mark Strong and Lesley Manville give powerhouse performances as Oedipus and his wife, Jacasta.  When the show played London’s West End last fall the production was nominated for four Olivier Awards, winning one for best revival and another for best actress.  I expect similar results with the Tonys in June, except I would honor Strong and Icke with top honors as well.

A taut two hours with no intermission, the show takes place in the present, although no location is mentioned.  Oedipus is a politician rather than a king and it’s election night after a hard-fought campaign that he is expected to win in a landslide.  

I liked Hildegard Bechtler’s single set, although it doesn’t look like any campaign office I’ve ever been in, and I’ve been in plenty as a former political reporter and press secretary.  It’s far too neat and sparse for a campaign office, even at the start of the effort, but it’s a good choice.  With little more than a large table with chairs at the center and a sofa on the far right, and with Natasha Chivers’s bright lighting, our attention is focused fully on the unfolding story.  One important detail is a digital clock measuring days, hours and minutes, ticking them down as the play progresses.

Before we get to this set, though, Tal Varden’s full stage, floor-to-ceiling video projection shows the candidate surrounded by supporters carrying Oedipus signs on sticks as he continues with his speechifying, using language that could be attributed to Zohran Mamdani or Barack Obama.

“They deliberately dragged us backwards to a time when the rich were rich, and the poor were poor, backwards to when people who weren’t like us deserved persecution, backwards until rumors and lies were the same as truth, and we’ve seen that in this campaign.  My opponent loves the idea this country isn’t my country.  He doesn’t say I couldn’t do the job.  He says I’m not from here.  My identity doesn’t fit.”

And he promises he will release his birth certificate to appease some critics.  Of course, unlike Barack Obama, we will learn that releasing his birth certificate is one promise Oedipus can’t keep.

Another reference to our times is when Jacasta is revealing her painful past.  She talks about the considerably older man who sexually abused her for years when she was a young teenager, which sounds like the testimony we’ve heard from Jeffrey Epstein’s victims.  I was amazed by Manville’s timing of this revelation.  As soon as she uttered the final word the digital clock went to 00.  I never saw her look at the clock and yet she timed her heartbreaking disclosure to the second.  This is especially impressive because Icke didn’t allow Manville and Strong to rehearse the horrifying conclusion until a week before previews began, telling the New York Times they “had to understand what was going to be lost before that loss counted for anything.”

The supporting characters are all skilled but the show belongs to Strong and Manville, who are onstage for nearly the entire, tense, two hours.